Composite decking vs patio tiles: Which should you choose?

Key highlights: 

• Enhanced outdoor living: Both composite decking and natural stone patio tiles offer unique aesthetic advantages for elevating outdoor spaces.
• Composite decking boards are more environmentally friendly than patio tiles: These stone tiles, however, can have a variable environmental impact, depending on the source and production.
• Design options: Look at the variety of colours, styles, and textures available to suit your taste.
• Comparing composite decking vs patio tiles: Learn more about which material suits your needs and requirements to find the right option.
• To conclude: Choosing between composite decking and patio tiles is ultimately your choice and personal preference after weighing their features against your wants for an outdoor space.

Creating an outdoor living area is a significant investment that requires careful consideration of the materials used. No matter your stylistic preferences, transforming this space is a great way to improve your home’s resale value and a practical solution to create a slip-resistant and workable exterior area. From a sleek patio to a warm new outdoor space, composite decking and patio stone tiles are both viable options to consider, which can shape your garden's aesthetics, functionality, and durability.

In this guide, we’ll explore the key features of composite decking and patio tiles, analysing their unique characteristics and comparing the advantages and disadvantages of each option.

Choosing composite decking: Benefits & key features

The composite material is a popular decking option, with composite decking gaining immense popularity as a practical alternative to traditional wooden decks. Typically, composite decking is made from a blend of wood fibres and recycled plastics. These boards provide the look of natural wood while offering enhanced durability and reduced maintenance needs.

Unlike other decking options, such as wooden decking , composite is easy to take care of and is highly resistant to fading, staining, or attracting insects. However, one disadvantage to be aware of is there lack of movement and aesthetic durability.

Their consistent quality and range of colours and textures make them versatile for outdoor living areas. Whether you want to replicate the classic wooden boards in brown hues, or a more modern grey , composite decking has options that match any home’s style.

For more information, read our guide on the benefits of composite decking here.

Differing from traditional composite decking, Millboard collections are completely wood-free. We create our composite decking from vintage oak boards for unique wood grains and a versatile appearance. From the beautiful prime oak to premium aged with our Weathered collection, there is something for every type of garden, no matter your stylistic preferences.

Request Free Sample

Choosing patio tiles for your outdoor space

Patio tiles, made from materials such as slate, porcelain, ceramic, concrete or stone, offer a distinctly different aesthetic to composite deck boards. In this article, we are comparing natural stone patio tiles against composite decking.

These tiles are an extremely popular landscaping material that require a level surface and is available in different textures and finishes. However, the patio style is not without its flaws.

Durability is a standout feature of the natural stone patio tiles. This patio style is highly resistant to wear and tear, making them a fantastic option that is well-suited to heavy foot traffic and outdoor exposure.

Natural stone patio tiles also have various design options, with numerous styles, textures, and colours available to suit varied preferences.

Comparing composite decking and patio tiles

Both composite decking and stone patio tiles have their advantages and ways to enhance an outdoor space.

The primary differences between the two materials are their design and use. Though both can be easy to maintain, the wrong type of either choice can lead to frequent upkeeping. For composite decking, the wrong choice may include a lack in movement and aesthetic durability, whereas low-cost patio tiles can easily chip and crack.

In the comparison table below, we have summarised the key features and differences of the two flooring options:

Overall, composite decking comes out on top in several categories. Though stone patio tiles offer a natural beauty look and are durable, they can require maintenance, particularly due to chipping, staining, scratching, and chipping. In particular wet conditions or incorrect layering, patio tiles may also cause occasional slips and accidents, unless treated with anti-slip coatings. Whereas some types of composite decking are naturally slip-resistant due to their structure.

What sets Millboard composite decking apart is its patented Lastane® top layer, which provides a highly slip-resistant finish for added safety during icy and wet weather. The unique Lastane® later helps ensure no splinters, making your outdoor space safe for bare feet, whilst helping maintain the authentic look of timber.

For more information on what Millboard composite decking is made from, read our full guide here.

Which material is better to maintain? Composite vs patio

Maintenance is a key consideration for outdoor flooring, especially in environments exposed to British weather. Composite decking handles heavy foot traffic and harsh weather conditions very well , and is highly scratch and stain resistant. Many composite decking options have warranties from 10 to 25 years, showing they are built to last - find out more about Millboard’s structural warranty here.

Read about choosing slip-resistant composite decking with our guide here.

Patio tiles are also very durable, as long as the right material is chosen, like strong natural stone. Homeowners should be aware, however, that grout lines can become stained or moss-covered over time, requiring scrubbing or chemical cleaning.

Additionally, natural stone tiles often need periodic sealing to prevent water absorption and staining, adding to the overall effort and cost.

Comparing the costs of composite decking and patio tiles

Cost is another critical factor when choosing between composite decking and patio tiles. While composite decking typically has a higher upfront cost, its low maintenance and long lifespan often can save future costs in the long run. The installation process for composite decking is often quicker and less labour-intensive, particularly with modern clip systems, reducing installation costs.

Patio tiles, on the other hand, can be less expensive initially, especially if materials like ceramic or concrete are used. However, the need for grout, sealing, and potentially complex groundwork can increase overall costs.

To find out how much your composite decking would cost, use the Millboard configuration tool here.

Design considerations: The stylistic options for composite decking and patio

Both composite decking and patio tiles offer versatility in design, but their aesthetic appeal differs. Natural stone patio tiles offer a broader range of patterns, from various shades and types, including limestone. They allow for creative layouts, such as mosaics or patterned arrangements, which can add visual interest to your outdoor area, including:

• Intricate patterns: Consider different coloured patio tiles to make mosaic or geometric patterns for an eye-catching design.
• Borders and accents: Use borders or accent tiles to define areas and add flair to your patio layout.

Meanwhile, composite decking is designed to replicate the appearance of natural wood, making it a great choice for those seeking a warm and traditional look. Its consistent surface texture also makes it suitable for large, cohesive spaces, particularly when used in an elevated deck configuration :

• Multi-level decks: Add different levels to your deck for more dimension and visual appeal.
• Built-in seating: Use built-in benches and planters to save space and improve functionality.
• Curved designs: Include curves in your deck for a more elegant and flowing look, such as the flexible Millboard Bullnose edging.

Read our guide on alternative uses of Millboard decking for more creative ideas.

Millboard composite decking collections are available in various colours depending on your style preferences. Our Enhanced Grain range comes in ten different colours; from Ancient Oak and Ashwood, which perfectly replicate the classic wood look, to more vibrant hues of red Jarrah and modern dark shades.

Browse the different colours below to find your perfect decking style:

To further protect the design of our boards and the natural look, Millboard also uses specially designed screws – our “lost head fixing system”. These fixings are created to be cosmetically hidden in our composite decking, so that no focus is taken from the board’s beauty.

For more information, read our Millboard guide to colour, including how to choose the right shade for your garden, or request a sample to test below.

Request Free Sample

Should You Choose Composite Decking or Patio Tiles for Your Outdoor Space?

The decision ultimately depends on your priorities. Composite decking is ideal for those who value durability, low maintenance, and a wood-like appearance without the worrying upkeep of natural wooden decking. Its sustainability credentials and ease of installation further enhance its appeal, making it the better option for many homeowners. On the other hand, patio tiles are better suited for those seeking a varied or high-end aesthetic and are willing to invest in more maintenance. By considering the benefits of both options, you can make a well-informed decision that aligns with your aesthetic preferences.

For homeowners looking to balance aesthetics with practicality, composite decking is often the best choice. Its minimal upkeep and ability to withstand British weather conditions make it a cost-effective and stylish option that will last a long time.

If you require more information, speak to our experts today! Our team will be able to help you make a decision regarding your outdoor space, offering guidance and support. Call us on 020 7643 9943.

Frequently asked questions

Which option is more eco-friendly: Composite decking or patio tiles?

Natural stone tiles, while eco-friendly, may require quarrying, which has a high environmental impact.

The sustainability of Millboard composite decking is further enhanced by its long lifespan, requiring less frequent replacement and reducing overall waste generation.

Read more about Millboard’s sustainability roadmap and goals here.

Does composite decking and patio tiles affect your property’s resale value?

Composite decking and nice patio setups can increase the value of your property. They do this by giving you more outdoor living space. However, how much added value depends on factors such as the quality of the material, design, and how it has been maintained.

Can composite decking and patio tiles be installed over existing outdoor flooring?

Stone patio tiles usually need a flat concrete base for installation. In contrast, composite decking is more flexible and can be placed over uneven ground.

At Millboard, we employ accredited and qualified decking installers who are trained to our high standards. Our approved installers are well-versed in the specific requirements of Millboard decking, guaranteeing a problem-free installation. Find your nearest installer here.